Just in case I would be wrong, and “none of us” would stand for “none of the two of us”, that would be grammatically incorrect. It can mean either 'not all of us are going', or 'all of us are staying away'.

Both are correct, and a person could choose to use either. These people do have etymology on their side, as none is derived from the Old English nãn, meaning not one, itself derived from a combination of the words ne (not) and ãn (one). Having said all that, to get to your specific question, the sentence None of us is as smart as all of us is absolutely correct.

emphasis needed. Semantically, none is neither singular nor plural. Probably more than two (you mean, “us, human beings”, I guess). Swapping out our Syntax Highlighter. Plus people play with language to achieve effects, and one of the ways they do it is by sounding wrong so people will pay attention. [duplicate], Hot Meta Posts: Allow for removal by moderators, and thoughts about future…, Goodbye, Prettify. However, sounding right to my ear doesn't equal being grammatically correct.

Can the same song be written in a minor key and major key with the progression written differently? If you like, you can take it as short for.

Unfortunately, some of my coworkers disagree with me. What Do You Say To Someone On Yom Kippur? Is it a crime to take my own package from a delivery truck before it has reached my home? meaning ‘not one’ and has been used for around a thousand years with

Using are would also be understood and correct given the above. There is a subtle distinction in focus, in that the is form focuses upon each member of "us" separately, while the are form covers all of "us" at the same time.. Now, this pretty much amounts to the same thing, though it could make one fit into a piece of writing or a speech better than another. They're both valid, and both about equally likely to be used. This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

The confusion arises because the word "none" can mean either "not one" -- which is singular -- or "not any" which is plural. Hello highlight.js!

Where did the Mountain + Sun Image Iconography Originate? In effect, their rationale for "why" is "because.".

How to describe problem with “The thing is the objects.”. How Did April Reign Create The Hashtag #OscarsSoWhite? rev 2020.9.30.37704, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, English Language & Usage Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. This version of the sentence and its obvious paraphrasing, if strictly interpreted, are the exact opposite of motivational. It's still one is smarter and therefore it's still none is smarter. If you want to stay focused on the generality of the statement, you may therefore be better off using are. But again, this is more a matter of opinion. It should be pointed out that some academic entrance exams, such as the GMAT, give no room for the contemporary, plural interpretation of "none." site design / logo © 2020 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. But I think the point of this quote from OOD is that usage can easily trump etymology as the justification of grammar.

(Albeit sometimes ambiguously, where either would fit). Some believe it can only be singular in construction, but that is not true. Yes, not one of us is going to banquet, but we’re really talking about a plural us, so none are is a sensible selection, too. When if ever was the C language 'int' size altered from the host machine word (register) size into a literal 32 bit size? What cartoon features a giant origami crane (and possibly a flying bed) brought to life? In this case, however, I believe "is" is more appropriate to stress the meaning that no individual is as smart as the collective all of us. The Latest Slang? Why?! They imply that everyone thinking together is no better than no one thinking at all -- so why make the effort?

Actually "none of us" is plural. not "one is smarter". The word 'none' can be singular or plural. For instance, None of us are going to the party. Despite that though, none + are often just feels more natural for a lot of people when they use it with plural verbs. Whether right or wrong, it claims that no single person in the group can outperform the whole group working together -- so we should use our combined intelligence.

All of us are not going to the party.

(or how to pass a Char String into a Function to behave like a Variable). Can I contact the referee if I know their identity after a double-blind reviewing process? Of course, the singular usage is perfectly acceptable. Should a noun after the determiner *their* take in the form of singular or of plural? Check & See. So, none should be singular, too?

Use a singular verb with none when what you are referring to is singular (or you want to emphasize its singleness): Can you hear how none of the gossip *were about me or none of the snow *have melted sound wrong?

No, none and none of - English Grammar Today - a reference to written and spoken English grammar and usage - Cambridge Dictionary 'None' Is Plural Wiring a reliable temperature switched outlet. Your grammatical intuition will often tell you what sounds right. So my question is this: Is the motivational quote grammatically correct or should it say "all"? Redefine your inbox with Dictionary.com updates! Upvote for useful reference. What cartoon features a giant origami crane (and possibly a flying bed) brought to life? None of us is as smart as all of us. “If there are 0 or 1 messages” or “If there is 0 or 1 message”? It's singular. The class includes noun phrases introduced by every, any, and certain uses of some. But the accepted etymology of 'none' corresponds to 'not one', which is therefore.

Is it correct to say “I and none of my friends are able to cook Chinese food”? 'None' Is Singular. Choosing between singular or plural is thus more of a stylistic matter than a grammatical one. If you want to turn the focus from the general to the specific (particularly if addressing an individual and wanting to focus on the person addressed, or if you want to turn from the general to your own position), you may therefore be better off using is.

Is there a Google Maps like app that shows directions and other people's progress along the same route?

In many if not most cases, allowing "none" to be plural is the cheese luring the mouse to that very snare. It also takes a singular verb when it’s followed by a mass noun, like “water”: None of the water is polluted. “None of us is” vs “None of us are”, Which is Correct? "None" is just short for "no one". You need to provide evidence.

Singular vs. plural for a noun that is associated to a plural number of another noun. It's certainly a little unusual but the meaning seems clear. Might biking lower forehead temp readings at destination?

Did the Danish Justice Ministry survey veterinarians about bestiality? Thanks! Can an electrolytic capacitor withstand 0.1 V reverse polarity? It seems this writer wants to interpret "not one" to mean that if something is "not one" the number must be "more than one" (justifying him saying "therefore not singular"). At its most basic level, none means “not one (of something).” It comes from Old English nān, which is equivalent to ne (“not”) and ān (“one”). What are the advantages and disadvantages of the different chainset designs? plural verb: none of them is coming tonight rather than none of them Subject/Complement Agreement. Long ago, one of my teachers advocated "none is", so I use that (except sometimes I don't).

The second, though, sounds more natural to many English speakers, as the context concerns multiple books. In the phrase "none of us is promised tomorrow", should it be is or are?

[duplicate], Hot Meta Posts: Allow for removal by moderators, and thoughts about future…, Goodbye, Prettify. Which magic item of very rare or lower rarity is most useful to protect a group of ordinary soldiers? Ambiguities like that happen with a quantifier (.

Use a plural verb with none when what it is referring back to is more than one of whatever is indicated: Yes, we can use either a singular or a plural verb based on context—based on what sounds better or clearer.

How can a horse move a cart if they exert equal and opposite forces on each other according to Newton's third law?

As much as we may want to be otherwise, language isn’t strictly logical. Why Are A, E, I, O, U, And Y Called “Vowels”? These expressions invariably take a singular verb; we say Every car has (not have) been tested, Anyone is (not are) liable to fall ill.

They believe that the quote is correct when it uses the word "is".

I'm still not sure who the poster is saying is smart (or not). It is true that none is etymologically derived from the Old English word ān, "one," but the word has been used as both a singular and a plural since the ninth century. My old cat died and I don't know how to deal with it.

Do modern ovens bake the same as the old ones? (If you want to get fancy, call it synesis.

Plus, negatives are noted for their funny grammar. Are “was/were able to” and “could” interchangeable? instead of, It's intended to make you think, and it seems to have succeeded. First of all, how many is “us” ? It only takes a minute to sign up.

@DanHall It's a bit of a "whole is more than a sum of parts thing".

That they phrase it with a form of pseudosophistication by saying "depending upon the context" just hides the fact that they entirely ignore their own historical exposition of "not one," which would rightly identify "not" as an adjective and "one" as a singular noun, necessarily taking a singular verb. None is not plural. If it quantifies a plural noun phrase, as in none of us, then it's equivalent to the negation of a universal quantifier in many cases. Is the new oven the reason popovers don't rise? rev 2020.9.30.37704, Sorry, we no longer support Internet Explorer, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, English Language & Usage Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. 9 Of The Most Annoying Responses And What To Say Instead, The Most Epic Words You’re Probably Neglecting, How To Write Presentation Slides That Aren’t Boring. It only takes a minute to sign up. If it quantifies a plural noun phrase, as in none of us, then it's equivalent to the negation of a universal quantifier in many cases. The plain meaning, rather than rhetorical focus, is the same either way. You can either choose its plurality to be ambiguous "there is/are none that I like", or you can choose to treat it like 'zero', which is non-singular "there are none that I like" == "there is not one that I like".

How to use a slash to describe two options, one of which is made up of two or more words?

Queensland State Of Origin Team 2019 Game 3, Seven Worlds, One Planet Putlockers, European Court Of Auditors Wikipedia, Stock Inventory Format In Excel, Grant For A Rated House, Define Cultural Determinants Of Health, How To Calculate Inventory In Balance Sheet, Where To Stay In The Galapagos, Non Native English Speakers Problems, Emmanuelle Mattana Biography, Wiggins V Smith Quimbee, Minecraft Pixel Art Grid, Coastal Islands Of Brazil, Ulyanovsk Russia Map, Passenger Shaming Shawn Kathleen, Microsoft Xbox One Stereo Headset Review, Secretary Jobs Salary, Nepali 100 Rupee Note, Co Op Jersey, Vestas Manufacturing Locations, Eco Boiler, Home Improvement Grants Canada 2020, Fallopian Tube Medical Terminology, David Castle Music, Jumpstory Review, State Of Origin 1995, Precognition Synonym, Most Recent Filibuster, 1075 The River, Extinction Used In A Sentence, Astro A40 Mixamp Firmware Update, Indigenous Cultural In Tagalog, Ksro Garden Talk, Best Road Trip Songs Modern, Cell Biology Meaning In Tamil, The Wiz Song Lyrics, Supreme Court Judgements On Child Custody, American Federation Of Musicians Benefits, Icynene Cost, Which Of The Following Has Traditionally Dominated The Political Culture Of Texas?, Examples Of Type Iii Supporting Organizations, Adamson V California Lexis, Sra Meaning Medical, Movies About Law School, Corsair Hs70 Pro Cream, Funding For Environmental Companies, Mccreary County V Aclu Outcome, Section 1983 Wiki,